We’re committed to providing an excellent service to the players and families at Cincy SC and an important way we measure that is through our annual Cincy SC Customer Satisfaction Survey.

Our 2025 survey reinforced what makes Cincy SC special—and helped us identify where we need to be better. We also filter responses by team and share anonymous feedback with our coaches so they can learn and improve.

High Level Stats

  • Our Net Promoter Score of 55.3 is considered “Amazing.”
  • 93.7% of our respondents would recommend Cincy SC to a friend.
  • 34% of our U15-and-under families responded, which is actually far below our historical average of about 50%.

The Big Picture

Chart showing how likely is it that you would recommend Cincy SC to a friend?

So what does that mean? This question is a business industry standard and it allows you to calculate a Net Promoter Score (NPS). “The creators of the NPS metric, Bain & Company, say an NPS score above 0 is good, above 20 is great and above 50 is amazing.” Ours is 55.3, which Bain considers “amazing,” but it’s actually pretty low for Cincy SC. Our last five years we’ve scored in the 63-69 range that would consistently make us the #1 rated company in many industries, so a score of 55.3 tells us we’ve slipped a bit and we’ve got work to do.

We asked our parents if how much they agreed with the following statements: “My child is learning” and “My child is having fun” (wearing out your kids isn’t the goal, just a side benefit). The scores below are good, but we always shoot for 100% of agreeing strongly to these statements.

Chart showing how respondents answered the question about whether their child was learning and having fun.

 

What You Said

The feedback was overwhelmingly positive. Families strongly believe Cincy SC delivers on its mission of player development, positive culture, and community. The club is widely viewed as a long-term “soccer home” for families, with many stating it is the best environment their child has experienced.

At the same time, families are invested enough to offer thoughtful, detailed feedback—primarily focused on transparency, competitive balance, communication consistency, and protecting the club’s community-first identity as it grows.

Word Cloud from 2024 CSat survey

Core Strengths (Consistent Across All Feedback)

1. Coaching Excellence

  • Coaching is the single strongest differentiator.
  • Coaches are described as knowledgeable, positive, demanding in healthy ways, and deeply invested in players.
  • Players are challenged while supported; confidence, discipline, and love of the game grow.
  • Multiple coaches are repeatedly praised by name, reinforcing strength across age groups.
  • Parents value no-yelling, constructive coaching and strong role modeling.

2. Player Development Philosophy

  • Clear focus on long-term development over short-term wins.
  • Emphasis on fundamentals, game IQ, teamwork, and holistic soccer.
  • Players try multiple positions and are encouraged to learn through mistakes.
  • Development of character, resilience, and sportsmanship is highly valued.

3. Culture & Community

  • Strong “family” feel is cited across nearly every response.
  • Sidelines are positive and respectful; parents appreciate clear expectations.
  • Players form meaningful friendships; parents feel connected and welcomed.
  • The club’s values—respect, humility, effort, integrity—stand out versus competitors.

4. Enjoyment & Retention

  • Kids are excited to attend practices and games and often rediscover their love of soccer.
  • Many families report improved confidence, motivation, and commitment from their children.
  • Parents repeatedly say they want to stay with Cincy SC long-term.

5. Communication & Organization (Strength with Caveats)

  • When executed well, communication is viewed as excellent.
  • Sprocket, Google calendars, and club emails are appreciated tools.
  • Families value transparency and access to coaches, directors, and owners.

Recurring Opportunities for Improvement

1. Competitive Balance & Team Placement

  • Some teams are consistently overmatched, leading to discouraging losses and long travel.
  • Some families want better league and tournament placement and clearer rationale for “playing up”.
  • There is tension between development-first messaging and families’ desire for meaningful, competitive games.

2. Transparency Around Pathways & Decisions

  • Families want clearer communication on how players move between levels and Premier vs. Elite expectations.
  • Parents are anxious about birth year to grade year transition for Fall 2026 and beyond.

3. Growth, Scale & “Business Feel”

  • Some families worry about the club becoming too large or revenue-focused – families chose Cincy SC for its community feel and want that protected as the club grows.
  • Some families are concerned about pressure to participate in optional programs, such as PIVO Academy or Team PIVO.

4. Communication Consistency & Logistics

  • Pain points include late schedule changes, incomplete calendars early in the season.
  • Families want earlier planning and fewer changes.

5. Training Structure & Environment

  • More situational training (set pieces, game scenarios, goalkeeper-specific)
  • Balanced turf and grass training
  • Fewer overcrowded sessions
  • Some younger or new players struggled with rotating groups or unclear team identity.

6. Coaching Conduct (Isolated but Important)

  • A very small number of serious concerns were raised regarding coach behavior or comments to players. Families expect swift correction and alignment with club values when issues arise.

Big Picture Takeaway

Cincy SC is deeply trusted and highly valued for its coaching, culture, and development-first philosophy. Families are not asking for a fundamental change in direction—they are asking for clarity, consistency, and protection of what already makes the club special.

If the club can:

  • Improve transparency around pathways and decisions
  • Ensure competitive balance and appropriate placement
  • Maintain strong communication as it scales

…it will continue to stand out as one of the most respected and loved clubs in the region.


We appreciate you!

We believe that feedback is a gift and we wanted to express our sincere thanks for those who responded. Feel free to share your comments or questions on this post or reach out to us. We recognize that each family’s experience is unique and summarized results don’t necessarily reflect their personal feelings.


Benchmark?

If you’re reading this and you’re a leader at another soccer or youth sports organization, please reach out to us. We’re happy to share our survey design and analysis process. We have trouble finding peers to benchmark with!


Who are we!? Cincy SC!!!