Background: We often enter training camp with rosters of different sizes at an age group. Normally this is because we’ve brought in several new players during tryouts, and we want to give them and our coaches a bit more time to find the right level for their development. Before we get too far into the season, we want to get our roster numbers balanced, which typically means 10-11 players on U9-U10 teams, 13-14 players on U11-U12 teams, and 15-18 players on U13+ teams.

We’re not trying to reshuffle all the players in the age group. We wouldn’t swap teams for two players simply because a player on the 2nd team had a better first week than a player on the 1st team. If that situation persisted throughout the season, we would might look to make a change before spring. But we want to assure everyone that in general, preseason training camp is not a time to redo tryouts.

Timing: Normally after the first week of Aug (preseason training camp). This is the sweet spot that gives us several sessions to evaluate players but allows us to get rosters set for the season ahead.

Communication method: Coach mentions to the player or parents that there is an opportunity to move teams and explains the reasons for it.

When the coaches of the sending and receiving teams have agreed, we move the player in the system (Sprocket) so as to share the new roster and schedule for the player. While parents are welcome to discuss the move with coaches or directors, we’d like the player to begin attending training and games with the new team immediately.

Once a move is confirmed, the coaches can inform the teams at training, without a lot of fanfare (coach of sending team lets team know that Ellie and Kate are moving to Premier. Coach of receiving team lets players know Ellie and Kate are joining). We don’t want to make it seem like a big deal because for every player that moves up a team, there are likely several that feel overlooked.

We typically do not follow up with a mass email to teams about the roster change either: although transparency is good, this can make it a bigger deal than it should be and imply that parents are expected to share or discuss this event. We can let the other players inform their parents.

Justification: Decisions are made based on the overall assessment by coaches including technical, tactical, physical, and mental development. We acknowledge that the process is not perfect, evaluations are subjective, and two coaches will often differ in their assessment of a player. At Cincy SC, there’s usually not a big difference between two adjacent teams. All have excellent, professional coaches, train the same amount, and play in competitive leagues and tournaments. We seek the best development environment for each player, and sometimes that comes on the lower level team for a “bubble” player where there’s a greater opportunity for playing time and leadership roles. (Net, team assignment isn’t a big deal, you’re at a great place, regardless.)

Next steps: We have already updated Sprocket for registration and our internal team assignments, which affects calendars and communications, etc. We also update the Team List, GotSport (home for our official league rosters), and team uniform packets. If the move creates a jersey number conflict, we attempt to resolve that by having the player swap jerseys with a member of their former team or with our club inventory.